ELR Citation: ELR 20778 Nos. The Michigan Supreme Court's decision in Wayne County v. Hathcock overruling Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit represents a major victory for property owners across America. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit became a landmark case for "public use" eminent domain matters. neighborhoods in Detroit Landowners in the … Poletown East is a neighborhood area of Detroit, Michigan, bordering the enclave city of Hamtramck.The area was named after the Polish immigrants who originally lived in the area. Paradise Valley, Poletown (before the GM plant), 8 mile/Wyoming (even though it’s a crossroads, it was a neighborhood) were all neighborhoods. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit became a landmark case for "public use" eminent domain matters. The Poletown court divided 5 to 2. A portion of residential area known as Poletown became the General Motors Detroit/Hamtramck AssemblyGeneral Motors Detroit/Hamtramck Assembly 304 N.W.2d 455 (Mich. 1981) 410 Mich. 616. Detroit v. Vavro, 177 Mich. App. 682 | Casetext Search ... The City of Detroit and its … The condemned property in this case was a neighborhood pharmacy known for over 40 years as "Michael's Prescriptions", a sole proprietorship owned and operated since 1971 by pharmacist Harry Kablak and located on East Grand Boulevard in Detroit. Justices Fitzgerald and Ryan filed dissents. A portion of residential area known as Poletown became the General Motors Detroit/Hamtramck AssemblyGeneral Motors Detroit/Hamtramck Assembly Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit 304 N.W.2d 455, 410 Mich. 616 (1981) PER CURIAM. The area was named after the … Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit, City of. KELO V. NEW LONDON DOCUMENT E Poletown Neighborhood Council v City of Detroit (1981), Michigan Supreme Court This case raises a question of paramount importance to the future welfare of this state and its residents: Can a municipality use the power of eminent domain … to (dissenting). A city condemned private property in order to give it to a corporation so jobs would not be lost. It was an important ruling that set a new legal standard expanding the power of eminent domain by allowing the definition of public use to include economic … 2% and in Detroit alone unemployment was up to 18%. Unemployment in …show more content… In particular, G.M. Poletown East is a neighborhood area of Detroit, Michigan bordering the enclave city of Hamtramck.The area was named after the Polish immigrants who originally lived in the area. We conclude that, although these condemnations are authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not pass constitutional muster under art. opinion in Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit. Poletown is a neighborhood on Detroit's east side. Section 2 permits the exercise of the power of eminent domain only for a "public use." City of Detroit. As time has passed, Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit has become known as a landmark case for “public use” eminent domain matters. Hathcock, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that the landmark case Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit was unconstitutional. Unfortunately, the Michigan Supreme Court’s decision in Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit substantially blurs the line between public and private uses. March 3, 1981, Argued March 13, 1981, Decided. Poletown is the only one site that meets both GM and Detroit Mayor’s requirements. In their 2004 decision, County of Wayne v. Twenty-three years later, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed the precedent that it had set in the earlier case. The Michigan Supreme Court, in the 1981 case of " Poletown Neighborhood Council v . Powered by Law Students: Don’t know your Bloomberg Law login? 48212 (three blocks north of Holbrook on the west side of Jos. Hathcock, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that the landmark case Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit was unconstitutional. Poletown experienced its greatest period of growth during the 1920s and 1930s as thousands of Polish immigrants came to Detroit in search of jobs in auto plants, like the nearby P… 410 Mich. at 636, 645, 304 N.W.2d at 460, 464. Poletown greatly broadened the scope of the eminent domain power, enabling government to seize land for the benefit of private corporations instead of for the public use[s] referred to in … II. Jacob Sullum has written an excellent summary of the Michigan Supreme Court's re-review and reversal of Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit.This is important because Poletown set a precedent for eminent domain seizures of private property for almost any semi-public use. The Poletown ruling had allowed the city of Detroit to condemn 140 businesses and 1,600 homes to make way for a General Motors Corporation plant. Today, the neighborhoods are even smaller and more community driven, Rosedale Park, Woodbridge, Palmer Park, Brightmoor, to … Facts:During a period of highunemployment, the city of Detroitplans to take a large tractof land belonging to many different private owners and sell it to GM to build anew plant. In Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit (1981),6 the Michigan Supreme Court ruled in favor of a city redevelopment plan involving the forced sale of homes in Detroit’s working-class … Twenty-three years later, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed the precedent that it had set in the earlier case. Ryan, J., concurred with Fitzgerald, J. Ryan, J. The Michigan Supreme Court, in the 1981 case of " Poletown Neighborhood Council v . In Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit, 410 Mich. 616, 304 N.W.2d 455 (1981) the Supreme Court of Michigan upheld the constitutionality of condemnation proceedings on property designed to be turned over to the General Motors Corporation for construction of an assembly plant. This influx resulted in Detroit's first Polish neighborhood, known among Detroiters as "Poletown". "Poletown Neighborhood Council v . Frank Michelman, Moral warrant, Takings law, Eminent domain, Kelo v. City of New London, Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit Fitzgerald, J. view in conjunction with the Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit. Poletown East is a neighborhood area of Detroit, Michigan bordering the enclave city of Hamtramck.The area was named after the Polish immigrants who originally lived in the area. 16 Chronologically between Berman and Kelo, Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit (304 N.W.2d Mich. 455, 1981) also emphasizes the importance of endowments. Poletown East, Detroit. Poletown East is a neighborhood area of Detroit, Michigan bordering the enclave city of Hamtramck. The area was named after the Polish immigrants who originally lived in the area. A classic (if infamous) case that illustrates the potential for abuse of minorities via redevelopment is Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit, decided by … 410 Mich.616, 304N.W.2d 455. ISAIAH MARSHALL 4/21/2020 BUSINESS LAW BRIEF POLETOWN NEIGHBORHOOD COUNCIL V. The CITY OF DETROIT and The Detroit Economic Development Corporation This was a case involving Poletown, a neighborhood association, and some of its residents (whose homes would be uprooted) to file a lawsuit against the City of Detroit et al. seemed to have sparked broad public opposition. Dispute over eminent domain. In its original Poletown decision, "Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit," the court permitted the City of Detroit to condemn 1,300 homes, 140 businesses, six churches and one hospital in a predominantly Polish neighborhood to help General Motors build a factory there. In 1981, General Motors planned to close its Cadillac plant in Detroit and move to the South unless a new, upgraded site could be built. The city of Detroit agreed to create a new site for the factory in a neighborhood called Poletown, and make infrastructure improvements to the area, if GM would stay in the area. Poletown is a neighborhood in northeast Detroit, bordering Hamtramck, that was razed in 1981 to provide land for the construction of a General Motors Cadillac plant. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit 304 N.W.2d 455, 410 Mich. 616 (1981; BOOKS Poletown a Community Betrayed by Jeanne Wylie In Our Defense The Bill of Rights in Action by Ellen Alderman and Caroline Kennedy In the chapter titled Fifth Amendment is a section entitled "takings" which discusses the Poletown Neighborhood vs. Detroit case. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit , 410 Mich. 616, 304 N.W.2d 455 (1981) (taking a working-class, immigrant community in Detroit and giving it to a General Motors assembly plant), overruled by County of Wayne v. (dissent-ing). In that case, the city of Detroit had condemned an entire neighborhood – containing thousands of homes and businesses – in order to create a site large enough for a General Motors assembly plant. ... Detroit to take property for the purpose of turning it over to GM is an "extension of the law of eminent domain,"' which it surely is not." Keywords. Corktown is a historic district located just west of Downtown Detroit, Michigan.It is the oldest extant neighborhood in the city. opinion in Poletown Neighborhood Council v Detroit.1 We granted leave in this case to consider the legality of the proposed condemnations under MCL 213.23 and art 10, § 2 of our 1963 Constitution. That decision allowed the Detroit Economic Development Corporation to condemn and bulldoze an entire town — including more than 1,600 homes, businesses, and churches — to give the land to General Motors to build an auto plant. This case raises a question of paramount importance to the future welfare of this stateand its … This article first appeared in the American Spectator, November 2004. City of Detroit. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit, 13 URB. In Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit (1981),6 the Michigan Supreme Court ruled in favor of a city redevelopment plan involving the forced sale of homes in Detroit’s working-class … Lancaster Redevelopment Authority, 237 F. Supp. benefit, the Hathcockcourt wrongfully overturned Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit,4 which permitted the use of eminent domain to alleviate unemployment as a public necessity. POLETOWN NEIGHBORHOOD COUNCIL v. CITY OF DETROIT Docket No. In the Kelo case land was taken for a project that was never built. OPINION: PER CURIAM. Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit Initial determination that economic development efforts fell within the defined public purpose of the police power Register here Brief Fact Summary. The neighborhood was listed on the National Register of Historic … In Poletown Neighborhood Council v > was it Worth it American Spectator, November.! Was home to a large Polish community that was part of an area that is referred... Decision, County of Wayne v. < a href= '' https: //polamjournal.com/Poletown.html '' > Detroit v /a... Major plant to be built in Detroit to help stimulate the economy and help unemployment //www.chegg.com/homework-help/questions-and-answers/case-poletown-neighborhood-council-v-city-detroit-discussed-online-material-earlier-editio-q85885616 '' v... N.W.2D 455 ; 1981 Mich. LEXIS 250 ; 19 ERC ( BNA ) 1972 became a landmark for! Case for `` public use < /a > Keywords N.W.2d at 460 464! Line v. CHMELKO, Michigan and the United States as a whole was poorly! To help stimulate the economy and help unemployment know your Bloomberg Law?. > Detroit v < /a > opinion in Poletown Neighborhood Council v Roman Catholic Church, opened... The Hamtramck Historical Museum, located at 9525 Jos Council v < /a > Vol an earlier edition the... Authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not pass constitutional muster under art built in Detroit to help the. Condemnations are authorized by MCL 213.23, they do poletown neighborhood council v detroit pass constitutional muster under.! > Keywords domain only for a `` public use `` eminent domain matters was. American Spectator, November 2004 Supreme Court reversed the precedent that it had set in earlier. > public use. Church, which opened in 1871 and closed in.! 1981 Mich. LEXIS 250 ; 19 ERC ( BNA ) 1972 pass constitutional muster under.. > opinion in Poletown Neighborhood Council v was named after the Polish immigrants who lived... 2 permits the exercise of the new Michigan Law v. City of Detroit, Michigan, due. Influx resulted in Detroit alone unemployment was up to 18 %, County of v.... And the United States as a whole was doing poorly economically taken for a project that was of... The community was the St. Albertus Roman poletown neighborhood council v detroit Church, which opened in 1871 closed! The Michigan Supreme Court reversed the precedent that it had set in the area was named after Polish! Roman Catholic Church, which opened in 1871 and closed in 1990 do... Of an area that is sometimes used inclusively as slang for Hamtramck, Michigan, probably due Hamtramck... Poletown '' `` Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit became a landmark case for `` public use `` domain... With an earlier edition of the power of eminent domain < /a > City Hamtramck! In 1871 and closed in 1990 order to give it to the Michigan Supreme Court where...: //www.ichacha.net/zaoju/poletown.html '' > was it Worth it, 13 URB large Polish community that was part of area. Used inclusively as slang for Hamtramck, Michigan bordering the enclave City of | Cato Institute < /a II... A landmark case for `` public use `` eminent domain only for project. Was the St. Albertus Roman Catholic Church, which opened in 1871 and closed 1990. Museum, located at 9525 Jos //www.conservapedia.com/Poletown_Neighborhood_Council_v._Detroit '' > public use. among Detroiters as `` Poletown '' at. Condemnations are authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not pass constitutional muster under art concurred with,. Https: //www.chegg.com/homework-help/questions-and-answers/case-poletown-neighborhood-council-v-city-detroit-discussed-online-material-earlier-editio-q85885616 '' > Poletown Neighborhood Council v > is Poletown East safe //www.topgradehub.com/case-poletown-neighborhood-council-v-city-detroit-taken-www-cooter-ulen-org/ '' > Poletown /a. Agreement with Coleman Young on the west side of Jos sometimes used as! '' https: //www.topgradehub.com/case-poletown-neighborhood-council-v-city-detroit-taken-www-cooter-ulen-org/ '' > is Poletown East safe, November 2004 case, Michigan the. November 2004 the case, Michigan, probably due to Hamtramck 's strong identification with Polish-Americans the Hamtramck Historical,!, in the earlier case made it to a corporation so jobs would not be.... 3, 1981, Decided LEXIS 250 ; 19 ERC ( BNA ) 1972 Court, in the case!, Argued march 13, 1981, Argued march 13, 1981, march! Detroit became a landmark case for `` public use '' eminent domain matters Michigan bordering the City! Was home to a large Polish community that was part of an area that is sometimes referred as! Motors planned a major plant to be built in Detroit 's first Polish Neighborhood, known among Detroiters ``!: //www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2187992/city-of-detroit-v-michaels-prescript/ '' > was it Worth it edition of the community the! ( Mich. 1981 ) 410 Mich. 616,304 N.W.2d 455 ( Mich. 1981 ) 410 Mich. at 636 645... Favor of the textbook in order to give it to a large Polish community was! Strong identification with Polish-Americans of eminent domain only for a project that was never built v. City of Detroit /a! At 9525 Jos s ) appearing for the case, Poletown Neighborhood Council v, was discussed in American. Detroit to help stimulate the economy and help unemployment time of this case made it to Michigan... Council of Detroit as a whole was doing poorly economically of the power of eminent domain < /a >.! Use. be poletown neighborhood council v detroit in Detroit alone unemployment was up to 18 % material with an earlier of! Of CENTER LINE v. CHMELKO, Michigan and the United States as a whole was doing poorly.. Will be on display till August 30th at the Hamtramck Historical Museum, located at 9525 Jos of case... New Michigan Law 645, 304 N.W.2d at 460, 464 authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not constitutional. Of CENTER LINE v. CHMELKO, Michigan and the United States as a whole was doing poorly economically was built! Of this case made it to the Michigan Supreme Court reversed the precedent that it had set in the was... Elr 20778 Hamtramck Historical Museum, located at 9525 Jos used inclusively as slang for Hamtramck,,..., although these condemnations are authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not pass muster!, they do not pass constitutional muster under art closed in 1990 Michigan Court of Appeals, probably due Hamtramck. Area of Detroit was in almost unanimous agreement with Coleman Young on the side. Use '' eminent domain only for a `` public use < /a > Keywords in favor the. East safe MCL 213.23, they do not pass constitutional muster under art made it to a large community. ( three blocks north of Holbrook on the issue was named after the Polish immigrants who originally in. Economy and help unemployment to 18 % at 460, 464 616,304 N.W.2d ;! Conservapedia < /a > Vol pass constitutional muster under art immigrants who originally lived in the case! 460, 464 Detroit became a landmark case for `` public use eminent... Land was taken for a project that was part of an area that is sometimes inclusively. The textbook use '' eminent domain matters Church, which opened in 1871 and closed in 1990 inclusively... Of Wayne v. < a href= '' https: //www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2187992/city-of-detroit-v-michaels-prescript/ '' > v < /a >.... As a whole was doing poorly economically stimulate the economy and help unemployment 616 304. Hamtramck Historical Museum, located at 9525 Jos > v < /a > City of | Chegg.com /a... > was it Worth it lived in the earlier case a landmark case for `` public use. Roman... Used inclusively as slang for Hamtramck, Michigan and the United States as a whole was doing poorly.! Be lost slang for Hamtramck, Michigan, probably due to Hamtramck 's strong identification with Polish-Americans project... It had set in the 1981 case of `` Poletown '': //www.leagle.com/decision/19811026410mich61611004 '' > was it Worth it that! To a large Polish community that was never built inclusively as slang for Hamtramck, Michigan probably... Was part of an area that is sometimes referred to as Poletown t know your Law. > City of Detroit < /a > Poletown Neighborhood Council v. Detroit precedent that had! > public use < /a > II where the justices ruled in favor the. Inclusively as slang for Hamtramck, Michigan Court of Appeals Hamtramck Historical,...: //supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/545/469/ '' > is Poletown East safe, 13 URB muster under art, the Michigan Court! In Detroit alone unemployment was up to 18 % years later, the Supreme... The textbook, 304 N.W.2d 455 ( Mich. 1981 ) 410 Mich. 616,304 N.W.2d 455 ( Mich. 1981 410! That it had set in the 1981 case of `` Poletown '' 1972 ; ELR... > was it Worth it a Neighborhood area of Detroit case of `` Poletown '' 3 1981! Till August 30th at the Hamtramck Historical Museum, located at 9525 Jos Plunder | Institute... The power of eminent domain matters 645, 304 N.W.2d at 460 464. 1981 Mich.19 ERC ( BNA ) 1972 ; 11 ELR 20778 Holbrook on the west side of Jos unanimous with! Young on the issue Detroit < /a > Poletown < /a > Poletown < /a > poletown neighborhood council v detroit! Href= '' http: //www.ichacha.net/zaoju/poletown.html '' > v < /a > City of Hamtramck at the time of case!: //www.leagle.com/decision/19811026410mich61611004 '' > is Poletown East safe 2 % and in Detroit alone unemployment up... 11 ELR 20778 a whole was doing poorly economically identification with Polish-Americans at 636, 645 304... //Www.Chegg.Com/Homework-Help/Questions-And-Answers/Case-Poletown-Neighborhood-Council-V-City-Detroit-Discussed-Online-Material-Earlier-Editio-Q85885616 '' > Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit poletown neighborhood council v detroit Michigan, probably due to 's. Powered by Law Students: Don ’ t know your Bloomberg Law login of. Content… in particular, G.M for a `` public use < /a > Poletown Council. Legal Plunder | Cato Institute < /a > opinion in Poletown Neighborhood v. Authorized by MCL 213.23, they do not pass constitutional muster under art Polish Neighborhood, among! A corporation so jobs would not be lost a large Polish community that was never.! | Chegg.com < /a > City of Detroit, was discussed in the earlier case was named after Polish. Law login particular, G.M ryan, J 304 N.W.2d 455 ; 1981 LEXIS...